Introduction

Higher Education Institutions work with a growing number of Third Party Vendors offering Cloud-based Solutions, learning Platforms & Administrative Tools. With these Partnerships comes the challenge of maintaining strong security standards. This is where the HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist becomes essential.

The Higher Education Community Vendor Assessment Toolkit [HECVAT] is a standardised questionnaire developed by the Higher Education community to help Institutions assess Vendor Security & Compliance Practices. This article explores the purpose, structure & importance of the  HECVAT Checklist in securing Sensitive Educational Data & maintaining Trust.

What is the HECVAT Trust & Security Checklist?

The HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist is a structured tool used by Colleges & Universities to evaluate the Cybersecurity Posture of Third Party Service Providers. It was developed by Internet2’s Higher Education Information Security Council [HEISC] in response to a need for standardisation in Vendor Risk Assessments.

Vendors complete the checklist to demonstrate their Security Practices across areas like Data Protection, System Monitoring & Incident Response. The Goal is to simplify & unify the vetting process while ensuring Institutions meet their Risk Management & Compliance Objectives.

Why Higher Education Institutions use HECVAT?

Universities often handle large volumes of Personally Identifiable Information [PII], Financial Records & Research Data. Using Third Party Platforms to store or process such Data introduces new Risks.

The HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist allows Institutions to:

• Ensure Vendors align with their Internal Security Policies
  
• Reduce duplicated work by adopting a Shared Assessment format
  
• Identify Gaps in Vendor practices before Contracts are signed
  
• Maintain Compliance with Frameworks like FERPA, HIPAA & GLBA

It ultimately helps Schools protect Digital Assets while promoting efficient Vendor onboarding.

Types of HECVAT Assessments

There are four (4) standardised Versions of the HECVAT to accommodate different Service levels & Data sensitivity:

• HECVAT Full – A comprehensive questionnaire for High-Risk Vendors
  
• HECVAT Lite – A shorter version for Low-Risk Vendors
  
• HECVAT On-Premise – Tailored for Vendors offering On-site Software Solutions
  
• HECVAT Cloud Broker Index – For Services that act as intermediaries managing multiple Cloud Platforms

Each Version of the HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist is available as a downloadable Spreadsheet, structured for easy review & completion.

Core Elements of the HECVAT Trust & Security Checklist

The Checklist covers multiple domains related to Vendor Security. These typically include:

• Access Control – How Users are Authenticated & Authorised
  
• Data Encryption – Practices for Securing Data in transit & at rest
  
• Business Continuity – Backup & Disaster Recovery processes
  
• Privacy protections – How User Data is collected & handled
  
• Incident Response – How Vendors respond to Breaches or Threats
  
• Security Certifications – Whether the Vendor complies with standards like ISO 27001 or SOC 2

By addressing each of these categories, the HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist offers a well-rounded view of a Vendor’s Security Posture.

HECVAT vs Other Security Questionnaires

Compared to general-purpose Security Questionnaires such as CAIQ or SIG, HECVAT is uniquely designed for the Higher Education Environment.

Unlike CAIQ which focuses on Cloud-specific Risk or SIG which targets Financial Services & Broader Enterprises, HECVAT:

• Uses terminology & Data categories familiar to Academia
  
• Includes Privacy & Accessibility considerations specific to Universities
  
• Prioritises ease of use & standardisation across the Academic Sector

Still, Vendors may choose to reuse answers from other Frameworks if there is overlap.

Challenges & Limitations of using HECVAT

Despite its value, the HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist has limitations. Some common challenges include:

• Time-consuming – Completing the Full Version can be intensive
  
• Lack of automation – Many Institutions still rely on Email & Spreadsheets
  
• Interpretation gaps – Different Schools may weigh answers differently
  
• Varying Vendor readiness – Especially Smaller Vendors may not have formalised Security Policies

While these hurdles can slow down Vendor reviews, collaboration between Security Teams & Vendors can streamline the process.

Steps to Complete the HECVAT Trust & Security Checklist

Here is a basic process Vendors can follow when responding:

1. Review the correct Version of the checklist requested
   
2. Assign internal roles to fill out relevant sections (IT, Legal, Compliance)
   
3. Provide supporting documents like Security Reports or Certifications
   
4. Validate responses for accuracy & completeness
   
5. Submit to the requesting Institution for review & feedback

Understanding expectations beforehand makes it easier to provide thorough & honest responses.

Tips for Vendors responding to HECVAT Requests

To succeed with the HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist, Vendors should:

• Maintain updated Security Documentation
  
• Build a centralised Compliance folder
  
• Seek guidance from Higher Education Clients to understand what matters most
  
• Avoid vague or incomplete answers
  
• Stay proactive in resolving identified Gaps

These practices not only help with HECVAT but improve overall Trust & Transparency with Institutional Clients.

How HECVAT supports Compliance & Risk Management?

The HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist helps Institutions meet Compliance obligations by documenting Third Party Risk evaluations. It supports:

• Audit readiness – With a record of Vendor Assessments
  
• Risk profiling – Helping classify Vendors based on Data sensitivity
  
• Policy enforcement – Ensuring alignment with Institutional Policies
  
• Continuous Improvement – Encouraging Vendors to strengthen Controls over time

In essence, it becomes a critical part of an Institution’s Security Governance Model.

Takeaways

• The HECVAT Trust and Security Checklist is a Vendor Risk Assessment Tool tailored to Higher Education.
  
• It helps evaluate Third Party Security & Privacy Practices before integration.
  
• Institutions use it to protect Sensitive Academic Data & meet Compliance Standards.
  
• Vendors should treat the checklist as a Partnership tool, not just a hurdle.
  
• While challenges exist, the benefits in Transparency & Security outweigh the drawbacks.

FAQ

Need help? 

Neumetric provides organisations the necessary help to achieve their Cybersecurity, Compliance, Governance, Privacy, Certifications & Pentesting goals. 

Organisations & Businesses, specifically those which provide SaaS & AI Solutions, usually need a Cybersecurity Partner for meeting & maintaining the ongoing Security & Privacy needs & requirements of their Clients & Customers. 

SOC 2, ISO 27001, ISO 42001, NIST, HIPAA, HECVAT, EU GDPR are some of the Frameworks that are served by Fusion – a centralised, automated, AI-enabled SaaS Solution created & managed by Neumetric. 

Reach out to us!